CHARLOTTE’S SECOND REBUTTAL
Filed Under: “Luna Has Lost Her Mind (Again)”
Prepared By: Charlotte de las Furias del Apocalipsis, Duchess of the Arctic Circle, Ruler of Common Sense, Owner of Scorchio
1. OPENING STATEMENT
Luna, my dear, you may clutch your binder and your organizational spreadsheets like a toddler clutching a security blanket, but I simply cannot allow these slanderous, binder-backed accusations to stand. Your counter-rebuttal was loud, chaotic, and, frankly, beneath my station.
We must restore dignity. My dignity.
2. ON LUNA CLAIMING SHE RUNS EVERYTHING
Sweetheart. No. You “run” things the way a Roomba “cleans”: chaotically, loudly, and with no awareness of what you’re bumping into.
Let’s review the hierarchy:
-
- I run the household.
-
- You run around the household.
-
- Ziggy runs absolutely nothing.
-
- Tartiflette runs disasters.
-
- Lilith runs shadow councils.
-
- Willow runs snack patrols.
The sooner you accept this administrative reality, the sooner we can return to peace.
3. ON MY SUPPOSED BREAKING OF THE “OMERTÀ”
First of all, Luna: I DO NOT SPEAK BREAKFAST.
You insist on yelling about omer-whatever, and all I hear is omelette, which is a peasant dish requiring whisking, which I do not do. Let’s be clear:
-
- I did not break an omertà.
-
- I did not break an omelette.
-
- I haven’t broken eggs in forever.
-
- The last time I interacted with eggs was when I knocked the carton off the counter for fun. That was art. That was seven years ago.
Your obsession with breakfast foods is your burden, not mine.
4. ON PLANTS AND THE SECRET TREAT STASH
Yes, I may have said something about plants and mentioned the secret treat location to Tartiflette. But consider, she asked very nicely and I was tired
If your “omertà” cannot withstand two eggs and a kitten in an apron, perhaps your code is fragile.
5. ON SCORCHIO’S LOYALTY
Let me correct this outrageous lie right now: Scorchio is not a “seasonal employee.” Scorchio is a mythical dragon of fire and chaos, and his allegiance lies with the one who truly understands him: Me.
You may have snacks, Luna, but I have flair. Dragons prefer flair.
6. ON MY “DIGNITY”
You claim I ran through the house with a plastic cauldron on my head. This is slander. I was wearing it. It was a look. One you clearly could not comprehend. Fashion is not chaos, fashion is vision. Some of us have it, some of us… have lousy binders.
7. ON THE SURGERY
You think you’ll be the one supervising iaia through recovery? Oh, Luna, you precious bean. NO.
I shall be perched gracefully on iaia’s chest, overseeing her vital signs and glaring at any cat who gets too close.
Your binder can supervise the socks. That is your lane.
8. CLOSING STATEMENT
In conclusion:
-
- I did not break an omelette.
-
- I did not break an omertà.
-
- I broke NOTHING except maybe a few hearts and a lamp.
-
- Luna is dramatic.
-
- I am correct.
-
- Scorchio agrees.
-
- Anyone who says otherwise will be hearing from my lawyers (who are invisible but extremely competent).
Signed with regal authority,
Charlotte, Duchess of the Artic Circle
********************************
LUNA’S COUNTER-COUNTER-REBUTTAL
Filed Under: Defamation, Breakfast Confusion, and Roomba-Related Insults
Prepared By: Luna M. Whiskers, COO, CFO of “I’m Done With This”
1. OPENING REMARKS
Charlotte. Charlotte. Charlotte. I read your rebuttal, set down my binder gently, took a deep breath…
…and then screamed into a laundry basket for seven minutes. Because you calling me a Roomba?
A ROOMBA? The DISRESPECT.
2. ON BEING CALLED A ROOMBA
Let me explain something extremely important: Roombas spin in circles because they have no plan.
I spin in circles because I’m surrounded by incompetence. BIG difference. Also, if I WERE a Roomba, at least I would CLEAN UP after the chaos tornado known as “Charlotte wearing a cauldron for fashion reasons.”
3. ON HIERARCHY
Your version of the “household hierarchy” is cute. Delusional, but cute. Let me present the REAL structure:
-
- Mama – Supreme Leader, Warm Lap Provider, Cookie Steward
-
- Me (Luna) – COO, Enforcer, Most Responsible Life Form Within 10 Miles
-
- Willow – Security & Snack Enforcement
-
- Lilith – Magic & Unexplained Noises
-
- Tartiflette – Junior Chaos Associate, Unpaid Intern, Probationary Forever
-
- Ziggy – Furniture
-
- Charlotte – Public Relations (talks a lot, contributes nothing)
-
- Collateral Damage – Still assessing the situation and his role
This is the truth. Print it. Frame it. Live it.
4. ON OMERTÀ VS. OMELETTE
I cannot BELIEVE we are still here. I say: “You broke the omertà.” Charlotte hears: “You scrambled breakfast wrong.” I say: “The code of silence.” Charlotte hears: “Add cheese next time.”
I swear to whiskers, this cat has subtitles inside her skull and they are WRONG.
5. ON SCORCHIO
I will not be intimidated by your oversized Home Depot dragon. Yes, Scorchio is dramatic, yes, he breathes fake fire, yes, he is your emotional service beast. And yes, you once cried on his foot when you couldn’t find your favorite toy. But let the record show: I am the one who plugged him in. Power = loyalty.
Sorry, Duchess.
6. ON FASHION
Charlotte: “It was a look.”
Me: “It was a CAULDRON.”
You can glue rhinestones to a traffic cone but it is STILL a traffic cone.
7. ON SURGERY SUPERVISION
You perched on mama’s chest? Great. Beautiful. Inspirational. But guess who will: bring the water, enforce the rest schedule, stop Tartiflette from turning the surgical bandage into a “fashion scarf”, prevent Willow from offering ham, prevent Lilith from summoning “healing spirits who might be raccoons”, record medications, guard the pillows AND keep mama from sneezing too hard?
Me.
You’re support. I’m logistics. Stay in your lane, Duchess.
8. CLOSING STATEMENT
In summary:
-
- I am not a Roomba.
-
- You DID break the omertà.
-
- You hear “omelette” because your brain is made of decorative feathers.
-
- Scorchio is plugged into MY outlet.
-
- I will run surgery recovery.
-
- You may hover like a dramatic chandelier.
-
- Tarti must be kept 30 ft away at all times.
-
- Ziggy is still asleep.
-
- I need a nap.
Signed with exasperation and impeccable organizational skill,
Luna M. Whiskers, COO, Professional Problem Solver • Binder Wielder • Absolutely Not a Roomba
CHARLOTTE’S THIRD REBUTTAL
Filed Under: How Dare She, Vol. III
Prepared By: Charlotte, Duchess of Artic Circle,
1. OPENING BROADSIDES
Luna. Luna, Luna, Luna. I was prepared to be civil. I was prepared to maintain decorum. But you crossed a line. A glittery, gold-embroidered line. You accused me of having a brain made of DECORATIVE FEATHERS.
This is libel. This is treason. This is… this is… downright poultry-themed disrespect.
2. ON MY BRAIN
Let the record state, for the minutes of this meeting:
-
- My brain is not feathers.
-
- My brain is not omelettes (though you insist on discussing them).
-
- My brain is not fluff.
-
- My brain is a highly advanced judgment center capable of evaluating everyone’s mistakes in under three seconds.
If anything, YOUR brain is feathers, judging by how often you panic when a door closes too loudly.
3. ON BEING CALLED “PUBLIC RELATIONS”
Oh, please. I am not “Public Relations.” I am “Public Revelation.” I reveal truths. Mainly about how wrong you are. Also, I do not “talk a lot.” I communicate. There is a difference.
4. ON THE CODE OF SILENCE
You keep yelling about this “omertà” like you’re in a Mafia movie. And MAYBE—just MAYBE— if you explained your rules without screaming, I would not confuse them with brunch.
You yell: “Charlotte, you broke the omertà!” I hear: “Charlotte, you burned the omelette!” One of these is a criminal offense. One is just Tuesday.
5. ON THE TREAT STASH INCIDENT
Yes, I told Tortilla Flat. But let’s explore why:
-
- You hid the treats in a box labeled “Boring Documents.”
-
- Tarti was playing next the box.
-
- I was supervising her chaos (someone has to, I am her combat nanny and not by choice).
-
- I opened the box to inspect, and boom—treats.
-
- What was I supposed to do? Not share information? I am a leader, not a miser.
If you wanted secrecy, you should have labeled the box “Vacuum Parts.” She would never have approached it.
6. ON SCORCHIO’S ALLEGIANCE
You plugged him in? HOW ADORABLE. That’s like saying you own the moon because you turned on a lamp. Scorchio is loyal to style, theatrics, and someone who can wear a cauldron without shame. Therefore: He is loyal to ME.
7. ON THE “CAULDRON INCIDENT”
It was FASHION. You are jealous. I looked mystical, powerful, avant-garde. You look like a tax auditor for snacks.
8. ON SURGERY SUPERVISION
You may claim logistics. You may claim organization. You may claim binders. But I claim presence.
I will sit on iaia gently, purr strategically, block her laptop so she actually rests, split the tangerine in segments of anyone who disturbs her (boy, I like this one), glare at everything else.
And you know what, Luna? Rest requires ambiance. That is my domain.
9. CLOSING REMARKS
To summarize:
-
- My brain is not made of feathers.
-
- The omelette thing is STILL your fault.
-
- Scorchio prefers me.
-
- You are dramatic.
-
- I am right.
-
- Treats should not be hidden in boring boxes.
-
- I will protect iaia with regal ferocity.
-
- And no matter how many binders you throw at me, I will ALWAYS be fabulous.
Signed with disdain, elegance, and zero remorse, I regret nothing.
Charlotte, Duchess of the Arctic Circle and fashion icon
